Why Are Cats More Likely to Be Strays?

When we think about stray animals, we often picture cats roaming neighborhoods, looking for food or shelter. But why are cats so much more likely to be found as strays than dogs? The answer may lie in the very history of how cats became domesticated—and how they continue to interact with humans today.
Cats’ increased likelihood of being strays is not a coincidence—it is tied to how they evolved alongside humans. Unlike dogs, who were bred and selected over thousands of years for specific roles like hunting, herding, and guarding, cats were not intentionally domesticated in the same way. Instead, cats likely domesticated themselves.
advertisement
The Original Cat Distribution System
The earliest domestic cats are believed to have been attracted to human settlements around 10,000 years ago. They found abundant food sources—primarily in the form of rodents. These wild ancestors of today’s domestic cats were not brought into human homes by people but rather wandered into them, forming a mutual relationship. Humans provided food and protection, and cats helped control pests. Over time, this relationship developed into the domesticated bond we recognize today, but the self-sufficiency of cats remained.
Cats did not experience the same human-directed selection pressures as dogs. As a result, they retained many of their wild instincts and behaviors, including their independent nature and territorial instincts.
Strays and Shelter Statistics
In the United States, approximately 6.3 million companion animals enter shelters annually, with 3.1 million dogs and 3.2 million cats. The number of dogs entering shelters has decreased over the years. Cats have consistently made up a larger proportion of the animals needing homes. More than 530,000 cats are euthanized annually in U.S. shelters, compared to 390,000 dogs.
Interestingly, 100,000 cats are returned to their owners each year after being found as strays. In contrast, more dogs (710,000) are returned to their owners from shelters.
Cats’ Path to Domestication
The fact that a significant percentage of cats are obtained as strays or adopted from shelters reflects their more independent history. While cats are still highly social animals, they typically don’t rely on humans for survival like dogs do. Instead, they’ve evolved into skilled hunters, often roaming neighborhoods and hunting independently. In many cases, they only form close bonds with humans when they choose to—whether through affection, food, or a comfortable environment and thus, the cat distribution system we know today.
This self-sufficient lifestyle allowed domestic cats to live outside human homes for extended periods. This explains why they are far more likely to be found as strays. Cats maintain a flexible social structure that allows them to adapt to various living conditions, from households with human companions to more independent outdoor lifestyles.
advertisement
The Changing Role of Cat Strays
While cats have traditionally been seen as more likely to live as strays, there is a growing recognition of the importance of responsible pet ownership and animal welfare. Efforts like trap-neuter-return (TNR) programs and increased adoption rates are beginning to curb the number of stray cats, especially in urban areas. However, the underlying reasons why cats are more likely to become strays remain rooted in their unique domestication story.

Featured Articles

Why Do Cats Roll Over Into Their Backs But Not Let You Touch Their Bellies?
It’s common knowledge dogs love to have their tummies rubbed when they freely lay down before you and roll onto their backs. But, if you’re also familiar with cats, you know that when they roll onto their backs with their bellies exposed, rubbing the belly will most likely result in…

Greebles and Cats: The Origin and the Meaning
You may have seen an internet sensation concerning cats labeled “greebles.” Feel out of the loop? We’re here to help you. In 2019, Reddit user /user/literallyatree commented on a Reddit post about a cat that looks like it’s trying to slap a ghost. This user commented: “My family calls things…

Polydactyl Cats: Just More Beans to Love
Polydactyl cats have become extremely popular in recent times. As a result, more and more people are interested in learning more about this six-toed cat and want to get one of their own. If you are a cat lover intrigued by polydactyl cats, you have come to the right place….